BOOK NOW
You Don't Need Everyone. You Need Your 2,000.

You Don't Need Everyone. You Need Your 2,000.

the obvious choice newsletter Oct 05, 2026

Be clear about whose lives you change, and the right people will find you.

This one began for me with a TV series called The Lost Kitchen. Besides movies, my greatest passion is culinary and food.


Not Built for Everyone

The Lost Kitchen is a 40-seat restaurant in Freedom, Maine. Population: a few hundred souls. Chef and owner Erin French built it in a restored 19th-century mill, and she did not build it for everyone. She built it for a certain kind of person. The kind who believes a meal can be more than food — that a single dinner can become a memory you carry for the rest of your life.

For them, she created an experience that feels like home. The kitchen sits right in the center of the room. The stove is in plain view. And everyone at the table feels like family.

When it opened, the phone would not stop ringing. So Erin made a decision that broke every rule of modern marketing.

She unplugged the phone and went offline.

If you want a seat at The Lost Kitchen, you mail her a postcard. A handwritten postcard. Then the staff draws cards at random and calls the lucky ones to offer them a reservation.

She wondered what any of us would wonder. In her memoir, Finding Freedom, she put it plainly:

“But the question remained, if I built it, would they come.”

— Erin French, Finding Freedom

They came.
Nearly 20,000 postcards. For 40 seats.

And to this day, if you want a table at The Lost Kitchen, it still starts with a postcard.

Erin French never chased an audience. She got radically clear about what she offered and who it was for, and the right people crossed the world to find her.


The Everybody Trap

Now let me tell you about a mistake I know personally.

For the first three to four years of my consulting practice, I tried to appeal to everyone. Every kind of business. My background was broad and my expertise was real — so why not?

Here's why not. I could never get clear about my own value, because I was trying to talk to everyone.

Yes. The branding guy fell into it too.

I call it the everybody trap: try to appeal to everyone, and you end up being chosen by no one.

When your story is written for everyone, it lands with no one. Nothing to hold onto. Nothing that touches your heart. You become one more capable firm in the sea of sameness, waiting for a phone that rings less than it should.

The fix lives at the opposite end. Get very clear about a small, specific group of people whose lives you can genuinely change. Know them deeply. Serve them completely.


How Small? Smaller Than You Think.

Kevin Kelly, the executive editor of Wired, wrote a famous essay called "1,000 True Fans." His argument: you don't need millions. You need a thousand people who believe in what you do so completely they'll buy whatever you offer. Seth Godin expanded this idea in his book Tribes. A small, loyal tribe is enough.

And here's what matters most: true fans are where the money lives.

They don't just buy more often. They gladly pay more for what they really want. They refer. They advocate. They come back. That's revenue, profit, and growth, all flowing from depth, not breadth.

Don't take my word for it. The Hinge Research Institute studies the fastest-growing professional services firms every year. The firms that grow four times faster and are up to 30% more profitable than their peers share one defining trait: they specialize. They serve a narrow market, and they offer up to 40% fewer services than firms that aren't growing at all.

Fewer people. Fewer offerings. Faster growth. That's the data behind Erin French's story.


Imagine Your 2,000

Imagine 2,000 clients and advocates who are your true and loyal fans. People who know exactly what you do, tell your story for you, and choose you without shopping around. Think how big your business could be. Think how it could thrive.

And if 2,000 sounds out of reach, you can start with one.

Sam Farber watched his wife Betsey struggle to hold a metal vegetable peeler because of her arthritis. So he set out to build one just for her, an audience of one. That peeler became OXO, a kitchen empire built on serving one person deeply enough that millions followed.

Try This Week

Sit down, by yourself or with two trusted people who know your business and are passionate about seeing it succeed. Pick the single customer who exemplifies the best relationship you have. Then write:

Who they are.
What their greatest need is.
What problem you solve for them.
How you change their life for the better.

That page is the beginning of your brand and your value proposition. Not a slogan. A clear picture of the people you serve and the change you make.

Clarity Changes Everything

Because that's what this lesson comes down to: clarity. Being clear on whom you serve and how you change their lives will, in the end, change everything for you.

Stop chasing everybody else's target. Stop chasing everybody else's customer.

Go and find the ones who need you more than anything else.

Branding Changes Everything®

Because clarity changes everything.


Office

Cincinnati, OH | Serving
Clients Nationwide
513.417.1885
[email protected]

SITE

Branding Your Business

Branding Yourself

About

Contact

RESOURCES

The Clarity Score

The Obvious Choice Blog

The Obvious Choice Playbook™

Case Studies

SUPPORT

Book a Strategy Session

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Still here? Let's talk!

One conversation is usually enough to see where your story breaks — and what to fix first.

Let's Chat!